Sunday, May 15

Hotcakes (1974)

Beatles fans refer to the 1968 album, officially titled The Beatles, as The White Album. But for Carly Simon fans "the white album" is unmistakably, undeniably Hotcakes. On the cover, the heavily pregnant singer glows with happiness in a setting so gleamingly white that it immediately conveys sun-drenched domesticity. Once again, the photographer was Ed Caraeff, but this was not another session on the smart streets of fashionable London. There is nothing jet set here. Instead, she is pictured in the kitchen of the house she shared with James Taylor, and in the months before the birth of their daughter, Sally.

The photograph and design concept perfectly represent a set of songs that opens by observing the madness of the world outside the home ("Safe and Sound"), and then extolls the virtues of daydreaming about love ("Mind on My Man"), of having a baby rock on your knee ("Think I'm Gonna Have a Baby"), of looking forward to looking back on a happy marriage ("Forever My Love"), and of turning away from angst and accepting happiness ("Misfit", "Haven't Got Time for the Pain").

This is not to say that the album represents a turn to the conventional or conservative. Her full-length white linen kaftan is one sign that the bohemian spirit lives on. Her broad smile also suggests the playful, intelligent humour found in many of these songs. And we should recall how unusual it was - and still is - for a singer to appear fully pregnant on an album cover. Had this ever been done before Hotcakes? Has it been done since?  It seems unlikely, and this cover is all the more remarkable given that, on the heels of No Secrets, she was the most popular and best-selling singer around. The autobiographical intensity of her singing and her songs has always been at the core of her appeal, though, and so it was entirely right that her pregnancy should be pictured in all its glory. Any thought of attempting to be discreet about it - for example by using the head-and-shoulders shots on the left, which came from the same session - was wisely rejected. Thankfully, the sixties-psychedelic backdrop was discarded too.

Many commentators have observed that Hotcakes can be seen as a marker of a wider social trend; that it emerged as American baby boomers, exhausted by the upheavals of Vietnam and Watergate era, settled down and hoped for quieter times. Yet the idea that this album somehow blended in, or simply reflected a wider zeitgeist, underestimates its originality. American rock music was driven by testosterone in the mid-1970s: by phallic guitars, crashing drums, and strutting popinjays. Even its more acoustic domain was dominated by drugstore cowboys. Carly Simon's music always served to expand the horizons of rock, and this ambition is proudly celebrated on the cover of Hotcakes.


  1. It never occurred to me before that the HOTCAKES album cover was so incredibly original and/or even radical for the time....(perhaps it still is!)

    How did the significance and uniqueness of this cover escape me after all these years? Isn't it ironic that all the attention to Carly's groundbreaking album cover work is focused on her sensual and sexy album covers? it would have been so business as usual to 'cover up' the pregnancy on the album cover, but once again Carly comes out with a cover that says 'here I am world!'

    She is no cookie cutter artist!

    Thank you for pointing out yet another example of how truly creative, open and forward-thinking Carly Simon is!

  2. i agree. i never thought how ground-breaking this image was/is. although her playing possum cover was post birth showing off an amazing body - carly remains an original. i have always loved this photo of her and i remember my brother giving this album to me for christmas. wrapped cleverly with an empty lipton tea box to disguise the "album" shape!!

  3. One reviewer theorized that showing a clearly pregnant Carly awashed in white pokes fun at virginity. Kinda reiterates the taunting "Daddy, I'm no virgin" line from the previous album. I'm buying this theory. It's a sly, humorous way to be provocative. Sounds like Carly to me!

    Carole King was pregnant on her "Music" album cover but covered by her piano. Rosanne Cash also on Rhythm & Romance, but her maternity clothes mask it.

  4. Walter, do you know anything about the necklace that Carly is wearing on the back of this album? White round beads and little elephants!

  5. Hello Diane. No I don't know anything about the necklace. Do you have a theory?

  6. Safe and Sound was censored in Spain printed album in 1974, the track was recovered in the european CD version printed in Holland for the CEE.
    I told it to Carly years ago.... she has not idea about it.

  7. I took the cover 'white' photograph in a bungalow at the Beverly Hills Hotel,
    James greeted me at the door.

  8. As a photographer I really love this album cover in particular. It was quite a challenge by 1974. Which camera or format did you use to take this album cover photograph Edmond Jay Caraeff? Regards
    P.S. It's true, here in Spain for some strange reason 'Safe & Sound' was banned for several years.